Home: Maucher Jenkins

Intellectual Property

Patents | Trade Marks | Designs

新闻与事件

新闻活动

Haas Formula I Car’s Stag’s Head Logo Bucked by IPEC

日期: 11 September 2019

EmailTwitterLinkedInXingWeChat

 

In ATB Sales Ltd v Rich Energy Ltd & Anor [2019] EWHC 1207 (IPEC) (14 May 2019), a copyright infringement claim, the claimants sought, amongst other things, an injunction which would require the removal of the stag’s head logo from the race car and website of the Rich Energy Haas Formula 1 motor racing team (below left).

 

Ultimately, the claimants succeeded, the IPEC also declaring invalid the registration of the defendant’s stag’s head logo (below right) as a UK

trade mark on the basis that its use was liable to be prevented under UK copyright law.

 

In coming to her decision, Her Honour Judge Melissa Clarke criticised the law firm acting for the defendants for describing a disclosure request by the other side as “imbecilic”, saying there were no circumstances where one solicitor should use such language in correspondence with another, and it was “far removed from the profession courtesy” expected. The judge also questioned the veracity of the witness evidence, and confirmed that there was no requirement for a claimant to plead fraud or dishonesty before trial if they later wished to challenge the authenticity of the defendant’s evidence.

 

stag_head1_170 stag_head2_174

Claimant's device           Defendant's device

 

 

Our article will be published in the upcoming Entertainment Law Review (2019), Issue 8: pages 267 to 270.

 

C
本网站使用cookies。

其中一些cookies是必要的,而另一些cookies则通过分析网站的使用方式来帮助我们改善您的用户体验。有关我们使用的cookies的更多详细信息,请查看我们的隐私政策

必要的Cookies

必要的cookies可实现网站核心功能。 没有这些cookies,网站将无法正常运行。这些cookies只能通过更改浏览器选项来禁用。

分析性Cookies

分析性cookies通过收集和报告使用信息帮助我们改进网站。

x